| Barclays
Global Investors Launches EAFE iShares
By John Spence
August 17, 2001 |
|
At long last, Barclays Global Investors (BGI) has answered the
call of indexers and today launched the new iShares MSCI EAFE
exchange-traded fund. Expense ratio: a razor-thin 0.35%.
The ETF is hitched to the new float-adjusted "provisional"
MSCI EAFE index. Index provider Morgan Stanley Capital International
(MSCI) is overhauling its equity indexes for free-float and increased
coverage, and in May it told
us what the rebalanced indexes will look like when the transition
is completed in May 2002. According to BGI, the new fund is an
optimized portfolio holding about 800 securities out of 1,040
in the provisional index.
BGI's timing of the MSCI Europe/Australia/Far East (EAFE) iShares
release couldn't have been much better. The San Francisco-based
fund manager believes the financial industry is looking for tools
to manage the switch, which is why it rebalanced
its 21 MSCI iShares to the provisional indexes earlier this summer.
"We wanted to bring a product to the market based on the
provisional MSCI indexes for two reasons," said Feng Ding,
emerging markets portfolio manager for BGI. "First, we can
help facilitate the switch for managers who are looking to make
the transition to the provisional indexes. Also, new investors
in the fund with a time horizon of longer than one year will not
have to endure the turnover and transaction costs necessary to
get to the rebalanced indexes."
BGI estimates that funds making the switch to the provisional
indexes will incur approximately 30% turnover this year.
The EAFE iShares are very competitive in terms of cost. For example,
the Fidelity Spartan International Index Fund and the Vanguard
Developed Markets Index Fund, which both track EAFE, have expense
ratios of 0.35% and 0.32%, respectively. According to Morningstar,
the expense ratio for the average actively-managed foreign stock
fund is 1.70%, and 0.97% for index funds that track the MSCI EAFE.
The chart below shows how the two categories have performed over
the last five years:
| Category |
YTD |
1 year |
3 year |
5 year |
| Active foreign stock funds |
-16.76% |
-22.50% |
1.67% |
4.71% |
| MSCI EAFE index funds |
-15.01% |
-22.55% |
0.06% |
4.81% |
Source: Morningstar, returns through 8/16/2001
Additionally, the unique "in kind" creation/redemption
process employed by ETFs should reduce taxes if the fund is held
in a taxable account. However, Morningstar analyst Christopher Traulsen
points out that ETFs can only be purchased through a broker, and
those commissions can add up over time, particularly if an investor
is making monthly contributions.
Still, the new EAFE iShares are a welcome addition for investors
who like ETFs, many of whom have been anxiously awaiting the launch
of the fund.
"I expect that the MSCI EAFE iShares will rapidly become
the most popular
of the international ETF offerings," says Gavin Quill, analyst
for Boston-based Financial Research Corporation. "It will
prove to be a very compelling
alternative to most broad-based international mutual funds."
Many advisors and analysts recommend diversifying a portfolio
with international exposure, although there is disagreement over
how much foreign markets are correlated with the U.S. market.
The graph below tracks the performance of the MSCI EAFE index
and S&P 500 back to 1969.

Sources: MSCI and Reuters
Round the Clock
Dow Jones Indexes announced it will extend real-time calculation
of the Dow
Jones Industrial Average to 13 hours a day beginning September
14.
The index will be calculated using component prices from the
Deutsche Borse's new U.S. market segment, which will be launched
on its electronic trading platform, Xetra. Dow Jones will also
use Xetra to price the U.S. and Asian components of the Dow
Jones Global Titans 50 index prior to the open of U.S. markets.
The indicative Industrial Average, priced using Xetra, will be
available in real-time from 3 am to 9:30 am EST. Dow Jones Indexes
said investors and market participants will benefit from more
timely dissemination of index values for the Industrial Average
and Global Titans 50 before the U.S. market opens.